Screening stupid subject lines |
Screening stupid subject lines |
Brian Chandler |
Nov 22 2011, 01:38 PM
Post
#1
|
Jocular coder Group: Members Posts: 2,460 Joined: 31-August 06 Member No.: 43 |
There are three posts in a row right now with titles along the lines of "I could really do with some help", "Really urgent help really needed". Isn't it about time these were rejected with a lesson on titles.
Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear, I suppose I have to add: of course this should be done automatically. If any title matching '%help%' (SQL: anything including 'help') were rejected, the lesson could include all the latest bother-subjects, like 'tumblr'. In practice it would be less irritating than the (с) and (г) destruction functions, because I can write around it. Try to find this "hеlp" with a search... In the next stage, all the tumblr posts could be shifted somewhere (the name would be independent of changes in the bother-subjects, with a lecture about that stuff. |
Darin McGrew |
Nov 23 2011, 02:11 AM
Post
#2
|
WDG Member Group: Root Admin Posts: 8,365 Joined: 4-August 06 From: Mountain View, CA Member No.: 3 |
I've thought that it could be useful to have a filter that rejects subject lines that are empty once you strip out all the stop words. Of course, on this forum, stop words would include "help" and "html" in addition to more common stop words like "the" and "for".
|
Brian Chandler |
Nov 23 2011, 02:29 AM
Post
#3
|
Jocular coder Group: Members Posts: 2,460 Joined: 31-August 06 Member No.: 43 |
Yes, rejecting empty titles once "stop words" are removed is the generic obvious idea, but would it work:
Could Use Some Help : is 'could' a stop word? Could you help please : ditto; and 'please'? HTML Urgent Help : is 'urgent'? The advantage of my suggestion is that it makes people write titles that *are* meaningful, not merely titles that contain something that might be useful. Another advantage is that it's simpler. |
Darin McGrew |
Nov 23 2011, 09:13 AM
Post
#4
|
WDG Member Group: Root Admin Posts: 8,365 Joined: 4-August 06 From: Mountain View, CA Member No.: 3 |
Yes, I think "could", "please", and "urgent" would be stop words on this forum.
|
pandy |
Nov 23 2011, 09:17 AM
Post
#5
|
🌟Computer says no🌟 Group: WDG Moderators Posts: 20,716 Joined: 9-August 06 Member No.: 6 |
Some beginners might not be capable to phrase their question better than "Help with HTML" or similar though. I mean, they know that it's HTML but that's about it.
|
Christian J |
Nov 23 2011, 10:12 AM
Post
#6
|
. Group: WDG Moderators Posts: 9,630 Joined: 10-August 06 Member No.: 7 |
As a reader, why not simply ignore threads with poor subject lines?
In order to help users create meaningful subjects, how about a polite nudge on the New Topic form page? I recall seeing that somewhere before, maybe it was on the old forum. |
pandy |
Nov 23 2011, 10:34 AM
Post
#7
|
🌟Computer says no🌟 Group: WDG Moderators Posts: 20,716 Joined: 9-August 06 Member No.: 6 |
Yar, the rules at the old forum were good! I want them back. I'd also like the old forum to be available as an archive, but no such luck I guess.
|
jimlongo |
Nov 28 2011, 07:30 PM
Post
#8
|
This is My Life Group: Members Posts: 1,128 Joined: 24-August 06 From: t-dot Member No.: 16 |
There are still rules "Read before Posting" at the top of every forum, with these guidelines . . .
QUOTE Make the title of your NewTopic meaningful and descriptive to those viewing the board. Include the code sections, or more preferably the URL of the page(s) you are discussing. Consider using the Search function at the top of the page to search for posts with problems similar to yours. Many times some other thread will give you clues to solve your problem on your own. but in a society where no one really reads directions what do you expect. An automated rejection of some sort might work, or it just might deter people from posting questions. If we stopped 50% of the posts, I guess you'd have a lot less problems with the topics posted. |
Christian J |
Nov 28 2011, 08:18 PM
Post
#9
|
. Group: WDG Moderators Posts: 9,630 Joined: 10-August 06 Member No.: 7 |
There are still rules "Read before Posting" at the top of every forum, with these guidelines . . . That's where they were! I don't even notice that pinned post myself. QUOTE but in a society where no one really reads directions what do you expect. In part this might be due to information overload for a new member, while once you've become familiar you've already become blind due to familiarity (like me). We could move the rules to the actual form page, but people may become blind to them there too. I'm sceptical about automatic rejections, it will probably annoy more innocent users (due to bugs) than stupid subject lines. A subject consisting of "Help" and nothing else might be safe to reject, though. |
Darin McGrew |
Nov 29 2011, 02:22 AM
Post
#10
|
WDG Member Group: Root Admin Posts: 8,365 Joined: 4-August 06 From: Mountain View, CA Member No.: 3 |
FWIW, I wasn't thinking of completely rejecting the post. I was thinking of some sort of "Are you sure?" response that would require an extra click. If they want to be oblivious, then they can be. But people who are more aware might learn something when encouraged to enter a more informative subject line.
|
pandy |
Nov 29 2011, 03:27 AM
Post
#11
|
🌟Computer says no🌟 Group: WDG Moderators Posts: 20,716 Joined: 9-August 06 Member No.: 6 |
Ah, that could work.
|
Ephraim F. Moya |
Dec 12 2011, 12:57 PM
Post
#12
|
Advanced Member Group: Members Posts: 167 Joined: 2-September 07 From: New Mexico Member No.: 3,702 |
Ah, that could work. You guys are ALL wrong. Not everyone can write. Good writing and good html are not related. If they feel a need to ask, do them the courtesy of at least reading their post. Then you can decide to answer or not answer on that basis. Since I came back a couple of months ago I've been struck by how long the top post stays on top. That means there are no new posts to replace the top one. By top I mean the one that is physically showing on the entry page for this software. This bbs is moribund. |
Ephraim F. Moya |
Dec 12 2011, 02:02 PM
Post
#13
|
Advanced Member Group: Members Posts: 167 Joined: 2-September 07 From: New Mexico Member No.: 3,702 |
/\
. . What does that mean? The same as this, I'll wager. . . \/ This post has been edited by Ephraim F. Moya: Dec 12 2011, 02:36 PM |
pandy |
Dec 12 2011, 02:14 PM
Post
#14
|
🌟Computer says no🌟 Group: WDG Moderators Posts: 20,716 Joined: 9-August 06 Member No.: 6 |
It means I posted in the wrong thread by mistake. Removed.
|
Lo-Fi Version | Time is now: 29th March 2024 - 02:10 AM |